Allstate Vs. Nationwide: What’s Best For You? (2024) (2024)

In This Review:

  • Allstate Vs. Nationwide Highlights
  • Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Coverage Comparison
  • Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Cost And Discounts
  • Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Ratings And Reviews
  • Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Our Take
  • Allstate Vs. Nationwide: FAQ

Written by:

Dash Lewis, Writer

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: What’s Best For You? (2024) (1)

Written by: Dash Lewis Content Writer

02/13/2024 09:20 AM

Compare rates from top providers all in one place


Key Points:

  • Both Allstate and Nationwide have strong customer satisfaction scores, though Allstate’s ratings are slightly higher in most regions.
  • Allstate offers more discounts than Nationwide, but Nationwide tends to have the best rates for most drivers.
  • Some drivers may find more comprehensive coverage and discount options through providers like State Farm or Geico.

If you’re comparing Allstate vs. Nationwide, you’re already on track to finding the right car insurance coverage for your needs. Our team has researched the best car insurance companies in the industry, and both Allstate and Nationwide are reputable providers with large coverage areas and a wide range of available insurance products.

Choosing between the two may present a challenge. That’s why we’re putting both insurance companies head-to-head to help you decide which may be the best choice. Allstate is known for extensive coverage and a network of local agents, while Nationwide has excellent coverage for seniors and uses modern technology. In this review, we’ll get into the details of each insurer.

Allstate Vs. Nationwide Highlights

Both Allstate and Nationwide are national auto insurance providers founded over 90 years ago that offer full and minimum coverage car insurance protection to customers across the United States.

Below, we show you how each provider scored during our research. While Allstate and Nationwide have similar overall ratings from our team, their scores in the reliability and cost categories show a notable difference. Overall, you can expect to pay more for a full coverage insurance policy from Allstate than you would for similar coverage from Nationwide.

Overall Rating4.44.4
Availability50 states46 states and Washington, D.C.
(not available in Alaska, Hawaii, and Louisiana)
Customer Service4.24.3
AM Best Financial Strength RatingA+A+
2023 J.D. Power Claims Satisfaction Score882/1,000875/1,000
Mobile App Google Play Rating3.84.4
Mobile App App Store Rating4.84.7

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Coverage Comparison

When shopping for car insurance, choosing an insurer with the right coverage options for your needs can provide peace of mind.

The table below compares Allstate vs. Nationwide in terms of coverage options. We find that Nationwide has a more comprehensive coverage selection than Allstate.

Bodily Injury Liability (BI)
Property Damage Liability (PD)
Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
Medical Payments (MedPay)
Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM)
Roadside Assistance
Rental Car Reimbursem*nt
Accident Forgiveness
Towing and Labor
Guaranteed Asset Protection (GAP) Insurance
Deductible Savings
Total Loss Deductible Waiver
Rideshare Insurance
Mexico Tourist Car Insurance

As you can see, like most car insurance companies, Allstate and Nationwide provide the six standard types of auto insurance coverage:

  • Liability auto insurance
  • Collision insurance
  • Comprehensive car insurance
  • Personal injury protection (PIP)
  • Medical payments (MedPay)
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage (UM/UIM)

You can also get roadside assistance, rental car reimbursem*nt, and accident forgiveness insurance with either company–all big pluses in an auto insurance provider. Beyond those, coverage varies between Allstate vs. Nationwide.

Allstate’s standout coverage offering is rideshare insurance. This type of coverage is for people who drive for a ridesharing service like Uber or Lyft. It covers the cost of injuries for you and your passengers after a covered accident. Plus, you get rental car reimbursem*nt if your car is in the shop after an accident.

Unlike Allstate, Nationwide offers a total loss waiver deductible. This option ensures your collision or comprehensive deductible will be waived in the event of a total loss.

We also think it’s important to mention Nationwide’s On Your Side® Review, even though it technically isn’t a type of insurance coverage. It includes a free consultation with a Nationwide agent to ensure you fully understand your policy and benefits and your current coverage satisfies your needs.

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Cost And Discounts

Our research found that Nationwide is generally more affordable than Allstate. However, car insurance rates depend on many factors, including your age, vehicle make and model, and driving history. For this reason, it doesn’t hurt to get free insurance quotes from both providers.

Allstate Vs. Nationwide Cost Comparison

The chart below shows a side-by-side comparison of annual rates for different types of insurance coverage and driver profiles.

Full coverage and liability estimates represent costs for a single male driver, age 30, with a 2020 Honda CR-V, good credit, and a clean driving record. For comparison, we also included average costs for younger drivers and drivers with a recent speeding ticket.

Our research found that Nationwide was more affordable for most drivers, including teen drivers and drivers with recent traffic violations. Nationwide’s full coverage rates are also below the national average of $1,968 per year, while Allstate car insurance is 28 percent higher.

Annual Rate
Annual Rate
Full coverage insurance$2,520$1,674
Liability coverage$1,036$770
Full coverage for drivers age 16$11,072$6,541
Full coverage for drivers with one ticket$2,911$2,149

Allstate Vs. Nationwide Discount Opportunities

When you compare rates between Allstate and Nationwide, consider the discounts you qualify for. Most major insurance providers allow customers to save money on insurance premiums by bundling auto, life, and home insurance policies, among other ways.

By the numbers, Allstate has more auto insurance discounts than Nationwide. Here are some ways you can save with each auto insurer:

Safe Driver
Automatic Payments
New Car
Anti-Lock Brakes
Early Signing
Responsible Payer
Pay in Full
Good Student
Defensive Driving
Low mileage

Between Allstate vs. Nationwide, we like Allstate’s discounts for good students and paying bills responsibly. Nationwide offers a great defensive driving discount and a program that gives discounts for driving less.

Drivewise® Vs. SmartRide®

Both Allstate and Nationwide have safe driver rewards programs in which a plug-in device or mobile app monitors your driving habits. Here’s a side-by-side look at Allstate’s Drivewise and Nationwide’s SmartRide programs.

Allstate DrivewiseNationwide SmartRide
Unspecified signup and renewal discount10% discount for signing up
Unspecified discount every six to 12 months for safe drivingUp to 40% off for safe driving
App has a 3.8-star rating on the Google Play Store and a 4.8 on the App StoreApp has a 4.4-star rating on the Google Play Store and a 4.7 on the App Store

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Quotes And Claims

You can get a quote for an auto insurance policy online or over the phone with both Allstate and Nationwide.

The J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Insurance Shopping Study℠surveyed drivers shopping for car insurance and measured price, distribution channel, and policy offerings. Allstate earned 853 points out of a possible 1,000 for customer satisfaction, and Nationwide earned 861 points. These numbers tell us that policyholders were slightly more satisfied with Nationwide’s shopping experience.

The J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Auto Claims Satisfaction Study℠gave Allstate a score of 882 points out of a possible 1,000, while Nationwide earned 875. Overall, customers are a bit more pleased with Allstate’s claims experience than Nationwide’s.

To get free quotes from Allstate and Nationwide, enter your zip code in the tool below.

Compare Car Insurance Rates

Enter your zip code to shop for the best rates in your area

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Ratings And Reviews

Allstate and Nationwide both have excellent insurance industry reputations, with high ratings from both AM Best and the Better Business Bureau (BBB). AM Best measures financial strength, which tells us how capable an auto insurance company is of paying out on claims, while the BBB reviews business practices and transparency.

AM Best Financial Strength RatingA+A
BBB RatingA+A+

To further compare Allstate vs. Nationwide, we can look at the J.D. Power 2023 U.S. Auto Insurance Study℠, which breaks down customer satisfaction by region. Check out the table below to see how customers in your region rated each insurance company. All ratings are based on a 1,000-point scale.

Central: Arkansas, Iowa, Kansas, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, Oklahoma, and South Dakota806792
Florida821Not rated
in this region
Mid-Atlantic: Delaware, Washington D.C., Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and West Virginia825820
New England: Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Vermont816Not rated
in this region
New York819800
North Central: Illinois, Indiana, Michigan, Ohio, and Wisconsin822821
Northwest: Idaho, Montana, Oregon, Washington, and Wyoming783Not rated
in this region
Southeast: Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, and Tennessee832834
Southwest: Arizona, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, and Utah801783
Texas809Not rated
in this region

According to the study, Allstate has a slightly higher level of customer satisfaction in more regions of the U.S.

Allstate vs. Nationwide: BBB Reviews

It’s normal for providers of this size to have mixed reviews on the BBB platform. Let’s take a closer look at what some BBB reviewers have to say when it comes to Allstate vs. Nationwide.

Positive Allstate reviews mention an easy, smooth claims process and good customer service. Complaints about the provider cite poor communication and a lack of professionalism. Those who praise Nationwide mention a quick claims and repair process, but displeased customers complain of bad customer service.

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: Our Take

Allstate and Nationwide both offer high-quality car insurance coverage and boast strong customer satisfaction ratings. While Allstate has slightly higher customer ratings, Nationwide wins out when it comes to cost, since it has lower rates for most drivers. Still, your insurance costs may depend on your driving history, credit score, discounts, and other factors.

Cost And DiscountsNationwide
Quotes And Claims ProcessesTie
Ratings And Customer ReviewsAllstate

We recommend getting quotes from multiple companies as you search for insurance options. Use our tool below to compare auto insurance rates in your area.

Compare Car Insurance Rates

Enter your zip code to shop for the best rates in your area

Other Recommended Car Insurance Companies

After comparing Allstate vs. Nationwide, take a look at a few more top auto insurance providers. Geico and State Farm both performed highly in our industry review, with State Farm earning 4.7 out of 5 and Geico rated at 4.5 out of 5. We named State Farm the Best Overall provider in the nation and Geico Best for Basic Coverage options.

State Farm: Best Overall

With State Farm auto insurance, you know you have coverage you can trust. The insurer received an A++ rating from AM Best and an A+ from the BBB. As the largest car insurance company in the nation, State Farm offers standard car insurance coverage and add-ons like rental car reimbursem*nt and travel expense coverage. Plus, State Farm has great mobile apps that can help you save money:

  • Drive Safe & Save™: This usage-based savings program monitors safe driving habits that could qualify you for discounts.
  • Steer Clear®: An educational safe driving app for young drivers, Steer Clear logs safe driving progress and qualifies drivers under age 25 for car insurance discounts.

Read more in our full State Farm insurance review.

Geico: Best for Basic Coverage

Geico auto insurance has a reputation for being very affordable and providing a wide range of choices for drivers. Like State Farm, this insurer has earned impressive ratings from experts like AM Best and the BBB, with scores of A++ and A+, respectively.

With Geico, you can get standard auto insurance coverage and more–like roadside assistance, rental car reimbursem*nt, and mechanical breakdown insurance, which is similar to an extended car warranty. Geico also has a number of discounts for military members, good students, safe drivers, and other groups.

Read more in our full Geico auto insurance review.

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: FAQ

Below are some frequently asked questions about Allstate Vs. Nationwide insurance coverage:

Can I buy Allstate or Nationwide insurance online?

Yes, you can request quotes and purchase car insurance coverage online from both Allstate and Nationwide. The online quote process is easy and free from most major insurance providers.

Is Nationwide cheaper than Allstate?

Nationwide car insurance coverage is cheaper than Allstate’s for many drivers. For a good driver, the average cost for full coverage from Nationwide is $1,674, 34 percent cheaper than Allstate’s annual average of $2,520.

Is Allstate better than Nationwide?

Ultimately, the best coverage will depend on your vehicle, driving history, budget, and other factors. According to J.D. Power, Allstate has slightly higher customer satisfaction ratings in most areas of the U.S. However, Nationwide’s customer satisfaction ratings aren’t far behind Allstate’s, and the company’s policies tend to be more affordable.

Why does Nationwide offer me different rates than Allstate?

Car insurance providers use a variety of factors to determine your quoted car insurance rates. If you’re receiving a lower quote from one company, that company may consider you a lower risk or offer more discounts than other companies you’ve received quotes from.

How We Rate Insurers

Our review process aims to deliver consistent and unbiased assessments of car insurance providers. While there are multiple qualities that make a car insurance company successful, our review team focuses on those we believe are the most important for consumers:

  • Cost: Cost can be difficult to compare between insurers because so many factors impact annual premiums. The cheapest insurer for one driver may not be the cheapest for another. To determine our cost score, we look at insurance rate estimates generated by Quadrant Information Services, discount opportunities, and consumer reports.
  • Coverage: To determine our coverage score, we look at the number of coverage options available as well as coverage limits and deductible options. Our ratings also take into account additional services and benefits like roadside assistance.
  • Reliability: It’s important that an auto insurer is able to meet its claims obligations. Companies with a strong financial strength rating from AM Best score best in this category. Established insurers with a long history of reliable service also receive positive marks.
  • Service: We comb through customer reviews on sites like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) to learn about customer experiences. Insurers with a low volume of complaints score well in this area. We also consider the claims process, giving higher ratings to car insurance providers that offer easy-to-use claims apps.

*Data accurate at time of publication.

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: What’s Best For You? (2024) (5)

Dash Lewis Content Writer

Allstate Vs. Nationwide: What’s Best For You? (2024) (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Melvina Ondricka

Last Updated:

Views: 6074

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (48 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Melvina Ondricka

Birthday: 2000-12-23

Address: Suite 382 139 Shaniqua Locks, Paulaborough, UT 90498

Phone: +636383657021

Job: Dynamic Government Specialist

Hobby: Kite flying, Watching movies, Knitting, Model building, Reading, Wood carving, Paintball

Introduction: My name is Melvina Ondricka, I am a helpful, fancy, friendly, innocent, outstanding, courageous, thoughtful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.